The sales of goods act , 1930

The Sale of Goods Act, 1930 | Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education
📚 Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, West Bengal
⚖️ The Sale of Goods Act, 1930
Act No. 3 of 1930

⚖️ The Sale of Goods Act, 1930 — Complete Educational Guide

A simple, human-friendly explanation for CA Members, Law Students & Professionals
📋 66 Sections | 7 Chapters | w.e.f. 1st July 1930

🎯 What is this Act? (In Simple Words)

Think of it like this — whenever you buy or sell anything moveable (a car, a mobile phone, a bag of rice, or even shares and stock), this Act governs the rules of that deal. It tells us: Who owns the goods? When does ownership transfer? What if something goes wrong? Who has what rights?

This Act was born out of the Indian Contract Act 1872. In 1930, Parliament said, "Let's give sale of goods its own dedicated law." And so, on 15th March 1930, it was enacted, coming into force on 1st July 1930.

📖 Chapter I — Preliminary

Covers definitions of Buyer, Seller, Goods, Delivery, Price, Specific Goods, etc. The foundation vocabulary of the entire Act.

Sections 1–3

📝 Chapter II — Formation of Contract

How is a sale contract formed? What are conditions & warranties? Existing vs future goods. Sale by description & sample.

Sections 4–17

🔄 Chapter III — Effects of Contract

When does property (ownership) pass? Risk transfer rules. Sale by non-owner. Transfer of title in tricky situations.

Sections 18–30

🚚 Chapter IV — Performance

Duties of seller & buyer. Rules of delivery — place, time, quantity, instalments. Buyer's right to inspect goods.

Sections 31–44

💰 Chapter V — Unpaid Seller

Who is an unpaid seller? Lien, Stoppage in Transit, Right of Re-Sale — three powerful weapons of an unpaid seller.

Sections 45–54

⚖️ Chapter VI — Suits for Breach

What remedies are available when contract is breached? Sue for price, damages, specific performance, interest, etc.

Sections 55–61

📌 Chapter VII — Miscellaneous

Exclusion of implied terms, auction sales, tax adjustments, reasonable time as fact, savings & repeals.

Sections 62–66
⚠️

📚 EDUCATIONAL DISCLAIMER: This resource is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal issues, consult a qualified legal practitioner. Content prepared by Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, West Bengal for academic and professional learning.

📖 Chapter I — Preliminary

Short Title, Extent, Commencement & Key Definitions
Sections 1, 2 & 3

S.1 Short Title, Extent & Commencement

  • Name of Act: The Sale of Goods Act, 1930 (Act No. 3 of 1930)
  • Enacted on: 15th March 1930
  • Came into force: 1st July 1930
  • Extends to: The whole of India (including J&K after 31-10-2019)
  • Purpose: To define and amend the law relating to sale of goods

S.2 Key Definitions — In Plain Language

This section is like the dictionary of the Act. Before reading any provision, you must know what these words mean:

🛒 Buyer
A person who buys or agrees to buy goods. Note: Even agreeing to buy makes you a buyer!
🏪 Seller
A person who sells or agrees to sell goods. Again, even agreeing counts!
📦 Goods
Every kind of moveable property EXCEPT actionable claims & money. Includes stocks, shares, growing crops, grass.
🎯 Specific Goods
Goods that are identified and agreed upon at the time the contract is made. (e.g., "That red car with registration MH-01-AB-1234")
🔮 Future Goods
Goods to be manufactured, produced, or acquired by the seller AFTER making the contract.
🚚 Delivery
Voluntary transfer of possession from one person to another. Key word: VOLUNTARY.
💵 Price
Money consideration for sale of goods. Note: Only MONEY — not goods for goods (that's barter, not sale).
📜 Document of Title
Bill of lading, railway receipt, warehouse keeper's certificate, etc. Whoever holds it has right to claim goods.
🏢 Mercantile Agent
Agent who, in the course of business, has authority to sell, buy, consign goods, or raise money on security of goods.
✅ Deliverable State
Goods are in a condition such that the buyer is bound to take delivery under the contract.
⚠️ Fault
Wrongful act or default — something done wrong, or something that should have been done but wasn't.
🏚️ Insolvent
A person who has ceased to pay debts in the ordinary course of business or cannot pay as they fall due.

S.3 Application of Indian Contract Act, 1872

💡 Simple Explanation: The Indian Contract Act 1872 is the "parent" law. This Act is like a "child" law. Whatever this Act doesn't cover, the Contract Act 1872 continues to apply — UNLESS it contradicts something specifically stated in this Act.
  • All unrepealed provisions of Indian Contract Act 1872 apply to contracts for sale of goods
  • Exception: Where the Sale of Goods Act has express (clear) provisions, those override the Contract Act
  • So rules on offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity, etc. from Contract Act still apply

📝 Chapter II — Formation of the Contract

Contract of Sale, Subject Matter, Price, Conditions & Warranties
Sections 4–17

S.4 Sale vs. Agreement to Sell

This is the most important distinction in this Act. Let's understand it in simple terms:

BasisSALEAGREEMENT TO SELL
Property TransferTransfers IMMEDIATELY at the time of contractTo be transferred at a FUTURE date or on a CONDITION
Type of ContractExecuted contractExecutory contract
RiskRisk passes to buyer immediatelyRisk remains with seller till property passes
If Goods PerishBuyer's loss (he's the owner)Seller's loss (he still owns them)
Right Against Third PartyBuyer can sue third partyBuyer cannot sue third party
Insolvency of BuyerSeller must deliver; gets rateable dividendSeller can refuse delivery; keep goods
Insolvency of SellerBuyer can claim goods from official receiverBuyer cannot claim goods; gets rateable dividend
📌 Golden Rule: An Agreement to Sell becomes a Sale automatically when the time elapses OR when the conditions are fulfilled!

S.5 How is a Contract of Sale Made?

  • By offer to buy or sell + acceptance of that offer — just like any contract!
  • Can provide for immediate delivery, or future delivery, or instalment delivery
  • Can be written, or oral, or partly written + partly oral, or even implied from conduct
  • No stamp duty or registration required for a simple contract of sale

S.6-8 Subject Matter — Types of Goods

Type of GoodsMeaningEffect if Goods Perish
Existing GoodsGoods owned/possessed by seller at time of contractS.7 applies — contract is VOID if goods perish before contract (unknown to seller)
Future GoodsGoods to be manufactured/acquired after contractContract operates as Agreement to Sell only
Specific GoodsIdentified and agreed upon goodsS.8 — Agreement avoided if goods perish after agreement but before risk passes
Contingent GoodsAcquisition depends on a contingencyTreated as future goods if contingency doesn't happen

S.9-10 The Price

  • Fixed by Contract: Most common — parties agree on a price
  • Agreed manner: Parties agree on how to determine price later
  • Course of dealing: Based on how parties have dealt in the past
  • Reasonable Price: If none of the above, buyer pays a REASONABLE price (depends on facts)
  • Valuation by Third Party (S.10): If third party can't/doesn't value → Agreement is AVOIDED (but if goods already delivered, pay reasonable price)

S.11-13 Conditions & Warranties — The Heart of Consumer Protection

These are the two types of promises a seller makes about the goods:

BasisCONDITIONWARRANTY
NatureESSENTIAL stipulation — goes to the ROOT of the contractCOLLATERAL stipulation — less important, secondary
Breach EffectBuyer can REPUDIATE the contract AND claim damagesBuyer can only claim DAMAGES — cannot reject goods
Example"This machine will produce 100 units/hour" — if it doesn't, buyer can return it"This machine has a 1-year warranty" — if parts fail, claim repair costs
S.13 RuleCondition can be TREATED as Warranty (when buyer accepts goods or contract is not severable)Warranty cannot be upgraded to Condition

S.14-17 Implied Conditions & Warranties

These are automatically included in every sale contract by law — even if not written!

📌 Section 14 — Implied Conditions as to Title:

  • Condition: Seller has the RIGHT to sell (or will have it at time of sale)
  • Warranty: Buyer shall have QUIET POSSESSION of the goods
  • Warranty: Goods shall be FREE FROM ENCUMBRANCES of any third party

📌 Section 15 — Sale by Description:

If goods are sold by description, there's an implied condition that goods MUST CORRESPOND WITH THE DESCRIPTION. Even if sale is by sample + description, both must match!

📌 Section 16 — Implied Conditions as to Quality/Fitness:

ClauseConditionException
S.16(1) — FitnessIf buyer tells seller the PURPOSE → seller must supply goods FIT for that purpose (if seller's skill is relied upon)Patent/Trade name goods — no fitness condition
S.16(2) — Merchantable QualityIf bought by description from dealer → goods must be of MERCHANTABLE QUALITYIf buyer examines goods — no condition for defects that examination should have revealed
S.16(3) — Trade UsageConditions/Warranties can be annexed by trade usage

📌 Section 17 — Sale by Sample:

  • Bulk must correspond with sample in quality
  • Buyer must have reasonable opportunity to compare bulk with sample
  • Goods must be free from hidden defects (defects not apparent on reasonable examination of sample)

🔄 Chapter III — Effects of the Contract

Transfer of Property, Risk, and Title
Sections 18–30

🎯 The Big Concept: When does OWNERSHIP pass?

This chapter answers the most critical question: At what exact moment does the buyer become the owner? This matters because — whoever is the owner at the time goods are lost or damaged, bears the RISK!

⚠️ S.26 Golden Rule: Risk passes WITH property (ownership). Unless otherwise agreed — whoever owns the goods, bears the risk of loss!

S.18-25 Rules for Transfer of Property

SectionSituationWhen Property Passes
S.18Unascertained goods (e.g., "10 kg rice from a 100 kg bag")NEVER passes until goods are ASCERTAINED (identified)
S.19Specific/ascertained goodsAt the time the PARTIES INTEND it to pass
S.20Specific goods in deliverable state — unconditional contractWhen CONTRACT IS MADE (even if payment/delivery postponed)
S.21Specific goods — seller must DO SOMETHING to make them deliverableWhen that thing is DONE and buyer is NOTIFIED
S.22Specific goods (deliverable) — seller must WEIGH/MEASURE to fix priceWhen weighing/measuring is DONE and buyer is NOTIFIED
S.23Unascertained/future goods — appropriation madeWhen goods are UNCONDITIONALLY APPROPRIATED to contract (with assent of both parties)
S.24Goods on approval / "on sale or return"When buyer SIGNIFIES APPROVAL, OR retains beyond agreed/reasonable time
S.25Seller RESERVES right of disposalWhen CONDITIONS imposed by seller are FULFILLED

S.27-30 Transfer of Title — "Nemo Dat" & Exceptions

🔑 The Nemo Dat Rule (S.27): "Nemo dat quod non habet" = You cannot give what you don't have. If you don't own goods, you cannot pass a good title to the buyer. The buyer gets NO BETTER title than the seller had!

⚡ Exceptions to Nemo Dat Rule (When buyer gets GOOD title even from non-owner):

SectionSituationBuyer Gets Good Title When...
S.27 ProvisoSale by Mercantile AgentAgent has possession with owner's consent, acts in ordinary course of business, buyer acts in GOOD FAITH
S.27 (Estoppel)Owner precluded by conductOwner's own conduct prevents him from denying seller's authority
S.28Sale by Joint OwnerOne joint owner has SOLE POSSESSION with permission, buyer buys in good faith without notice
S.29Sale under Voidable ContractSeller obtained possession under voidable contract, contract NOT YET rescinded, buyer buys in good faith
S.30(1)Seller in Possession after SaleOriginal seller delivers/transfers to new buyer in good faith — new buyer gets good title
S.30(2)Buyer in Possession before SaleBuyer with seller's consent obtains possession before property passes — can pass good title to third party

🚚 Chapter IV — Performance of the Contract

Duties of Seller & Buyer, Rules of Delivery, Acceptance
Sections 31–44

S.31-32 Basic Duties

PartyPrimary DutyHow they are linked?
SellerTo DELIVER the goods to the buyerS.32: Concurrent Conditions — Delivery & Payment happen simultaneously. Seller must be ready to give goods, Buyer must be ready to pay. Neither can demand performance without being ready themselves.
BuyerTo ACCEPT the goods and PAY for them

S.33-40 Rules as to Delivery

  • What is Delivery (S.33)? Anything agreed to be delivery OR putting goods in buyer's possession or possession of someone on buyer's behalf
  • Part Delivery (S.34): Part delivery in progress of whole = delivery of whole (for property passing). BUT part with intention of severing = NOT delivery of rest
  • Who applies for delivery (S.35)? Unless there's an express contract, Seller is NOT bound to deliver until Buyer APPLIES for delivery
  • Place of Delivery (S.36): As per contract; if not stated — where goods are at time of sale
  • Time (S.36): If not fixed — seller must send within REASONABLE TIME
  • Third Party Possession (S.36): If goods are with a third party — no delivery until third party ACKNOWLEDGES to buyer
  • Expense (S.36): Unless agreed otherwise, seller bears expense of putting goods in deliverable state

📦 Section 37 — Delivery of Wrong Quantity:

SituationBuyer's Right
Seller delivers LESS than contractedBuyer may REJECT; OR accept and pay at contract rate
Seller delivers MORE than contractedBuyer may accept contracted quantity + reject rest; OR reject the whole; OR accept whole at contract rate
Seller delivers contracted goods MIXED with other goodsBuyer may accept contracted goods + reject rest; OR reject the whole

S.41-44 Examination & Acceptance

  • Right to Examine (S.41): If buyer hasn't examined goods — he is NOT deemed to have accepted them unless he's had a REASONABLE OPPORTUNITY to examine them
  • When is Acceptance (S.42)? (a) Buyer INTIMATES acceptance to seller; OR (b) Buyer does any act INCONSISTENT with seller's ownership (like reselling); OR (c) After REASONABLE TIME, buyer retains goods without rejection notice
  • Rejected Goods (S.43): Buyer is NOT bound to RETURN rejected goods. Intimating rejection is enough.
  • Buyer's Liability for Non-Delivery (S.44): If seller is ready to deliver and buyer doesn't take within reasonable time → buyer is liable for loss + reasonable storage charges

💰 Chapter V — Rights of Unpaid Seller

Who is an Unpaid Seller? Lien, Stoppage in Transit, Right of Re-Sale
Sections 45–54

S.45 Who is an "Unpaid Seller"?

🔴 A seller is UNPAID when: (a) Whole price has NOT been paid or tendered; OR (b) A bill of exchange/negotiable instrument was taken as conditional payment AND the condition has NOT been fulfilled (e.g., cheque bounced)
✅ Even if property has passed to buyer, the unpaid seller has special rights AGAINST THE GOODS!

S.46-54 Three Rights of Unpaid Seller

RightMeaningWhen Available?How Lost?
1. LIEN (S.47-49) Right to RETAIN goods until payment. Like a mechanic refusing to return your car until you pay the bill! (a) Sold without credit; (b) Credit period expired; (c) Buyer insolvent Delivers goods to carrier without reserving right; Buyer lawfully obtains possession; Waiver
2. STOPPAGE IN TRANSIT (S.50-52) Right to STOP goods while they are being transported (in transit) — like intercepting a delivery! Only when buyer is INSOLVENT and goods are still IN TRANSIT Transit ends (buyer takes delivery); Carrier acknowledges holding for buyer; Wrongful refusal by carrier
3. RIGHT OF RE-SALE (S.54) Right to RESELL the goods to recover price Perishable goods (no notice needed); Non-perishable — only after giving notice to buyer If resale expressly reserved in contract — no notice needed; Original contract rescinded

⏱️ Section 51 — When is Transit ONGOING vs ENDED?

  • Transit BEGINS when goods are delivered to carrier/bailee for transmission to buyer
  • Transit ENDS when buyer or his agent takes delivery from carrier
  • Transit also ends if carrier acknowledges holding goods on behalf of buyer at destination
  • If goods REJECTED by buyer, carrier still holding them = transit NOT ended

📌 Section 53 — Effect of Sub-Sale by Buyer:

Generally, unpaid seller's lien/stoppage rights are NOT affected by buyer's sub-sale. Exception: If buyer transferred a DOCUMENT OF TITLE to a good-faith purchaser for consideration — seller's lien is DEFEATED!

⚖️ Chapter VI — Suits for Breach of Contract

Remedies Available to Buyer and Seller When Contract is Broken
Sections 55–61

🎯 Overview of Remedies

SectionRemedyWho Can Claim?Situation
S.55Suit for PriceSELLERProperty passed to buyer AND buyer wrongfully refuses to pay; OR price payable on certain date regardless of delivery
S.56Damages for Non-AcceptanceSELLERBuyer wrongfully refuses to accept and pay
S.57Damages for Non-DeliveryBUYERSeller wrongfully refuses/neglects to deliver goods
S.58Specific PerformanceBUYERBreach of contract to deliver specific/ascertained goods — Court can order seller to actually deliver
S.59Remedy for Breach of WarrantyBUYERSeller breaches warranty — buyer can (a) deduct from price, OR (b) sue for damages
S.60Anticipatory BreachEither partyEither party repudiates before due date — other party can wait OR treat as rescinded and sue immediately
S.61Interest & Special DamagesEither partyCourt may award interest on price — from date of tender of goods or price payable (to seller); from date of payment (to buyer)

S.58 Specific Performance — Special Remedy

💡 In normal breach cases, you get MONEY (damages). But specific goods are UNIQUE — you can't just buy them elsewhere! So the court can ORDER the seller to actually hand over those specific goods. This remedy is subject to the Specific Relief Act provisions.
  • Available only for specific or ascertained goods
  • Court has discretion — "if it thinks fit"
  • Decree can be unconditional or with conditions (payment, damages, etc.)
  • Application can be made at any time before the decree

S.59 Remedy for Breach of Warranty

  • Breach of warranty → Buyer CANNOT reject goods (warranty is not that serious)
  • Buyer CAN: (a) Deduct breach amount from price; OR (b) Sue seller for damages
  • Buyer can do BOTH — deduct AND sue for further damage suffered

📌 Chapter VII — Miscellaneous

Exclusion of Terms, Auction Sales, Tax Adjustments, Savings
Sections 62–66

S.62 Exclusion of Implied Terms

⚡ Parties CAN contract out of (exclude) implied terms and conditions by: (a) EXPRESS AGREEMENT; OR (b) COURSE OF DEALING between parties; OR (c) TRADE USAGE that binds both parties

So if you write in your contract "no implied conditions about quality" — that overrides S.16's implied conditions of quality/fitness!

S.64 Auction Sales — Special Rules

  • Lots: Goods put up in lots — each lot is a SEPARATE contract
  • Completion: Sale is COMPLETE when auctioneer announces completion (fall of hammer or other customary manner)
  • Retract bid: Until announcement, ANY bidder can RETRACT his bid
  • Seller's right to bid: Must be EXPRESSLY RESERVED; only one person can bid on seller's behalf
  • Secret bidding by seller: If not notified, seller CANNOT bid — sale may be treated as FRAUDULENT by buyer
  • Reserve Price: Sale can be notified as subject to a reserve/upset price
  • Pretended Bidding: If seller uses pretended bids to raise price — sale is VOIDABLE at buyer's option

S.64A Tax Adjustments in Contracts

SituationEffect on Contract Price
Tax IMPOSED or INCREASED after contractSeller can ADD the tax amount to contract price and recover it from buyer
Tax DECREASED or REMITTED after contractBuyer can DEDUCT the decreased tax from contract price
Taxes coveredCustoms duty, Excise duty, Tax on sale/purchase of goods

S.63 & 66 Reasonable Time & Savings

  • S.63: What is "reasonable time"? It's a QUESTION OF FACT — depends on circumstances
  • S.66 — Savings: Act does not affect rights/liabilities already acquired BEFORE the Act commenced
  • Rules of insolvency relating to sale contracts continue to apply
  • Act does NOT apply to transactions in FORM of sale but INTENDED as mortgage, pledge, charge, or security
⚠️

📚 EDUCATIONAL DISCLAIMER: This resource is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prepared by Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, West Bengal for ICAI Members, Law Students, and Professionals.

📊 Flowchart — Journey Through a Sale of Goods Transaction

START: Sale Transaction STEP 1: Contract Formation (S.4-5) Offer to buy/sell + Acceptance → Contract of Sale Property passes NOW? (Sale vs Agreement to Sell) YES → SALE Property & Risk Pass Now NO → AGMT Future transfer on condition STEP 2: Conditions & Warranties (S.11-17) Title (S.14), Description (S.15), Quality (S.16), Sample (S.17) STEP 3: Transfer of Property (S.18-26) Rules for when ownership passes (S.20-24) + Risk follows property STEP 4: Performance (S.31-44) Delivery by Seller ↔ Payment & Acceptance by Buyer Full Payment Made? (S.45 — Unpaid Seller?) YES Contract Fulfilled ✅ NO Unpaid Seller Rights (S.46-54) STEP 5: Unpaid Seller's Rights (S.46-54) 1. Lien (S.47-49) — Retain goods 2. Stoppage in Transit (S.50-52) — Stop goods 3. Right of Re-Sale (S.54) — Resell goods Contract Breached? (Either party defaults) NO Contract Complete ✅ YES Suits for Breach (Ch VI) STEP 6: Suits for Breach (S.55-61) Seller: Sue for Price (S.55) | Damages for Non-Acceptance (S.56) Buyer: Damages for Non-Delivery (S.57) | Specific Performance (S.58) Both: Interest & Special Damages (S.61) Chapter VII: Miscellaneous (S.62-66) Exclusion of terms | Auction | Tax Adjustments | Savings END: Transaction Resolved ✅ ⚠️ Educational Purpose Only | Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, WB This flowchart does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified legal practitioner for specific matters.

🧠 Mind Map — The Sale of Goods Act, 1930

Sale of Goods Act, 1930 Ch.I: Preliminary S.1-3 | Definitions Buyer, Seller Definitions (S.2) Goods, Delivery Price, Title (S.2) Ch.II: Formation S.4-17 | Contract Sale vs Agmt to Sell (S.4) Key Difference Conditions & Warranties (S.12-17) Fitness/Merchantable Quality (S.16) Ch.III: Effects S.18-30 | Property+Title Transfer of Property (S.18-25) Risk passes with Property (S.26) Transfer of Title (S.27-30) Ch.IV: Performance S.31-44 | Delivery Delivery Rules (S.33-40) Acceptance (S.41-44) Ch.V: Unpaid Seller S.45-54 | Rights Lien (S.47) Retain goods Stoppage in Transit (S.50) Right of Re-Sale (S.54) Ch.VI: Suits for Breach S.55-61 | Remedies Seller's Remedies S.55-56 Buyer's Remedies S.57-59 Interest & Damages S.60-61 Ch.VII: Miscellaneous S.62-66 | Misc Provisions Auction Sales (S.64) Tax Adjustments (S.64A) ⚠️ Educational Resource | Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, WB This mind map does not constitute legal advice.

🗺️ Roadmap — Journey Through the Sale of Goods Act, 1930

ACT 1930 The Sale of Goods Act, 1930 Act No. 3 of 1930 | Came into force 1st July 1930 7 Chapters | 66 Sections | Governs ALL moveable goods CH I Chapter I — Preliminary (S.1-3) Definitions: Buyer, Seller, Goods, Price, Delivery Specific Goods, Future Goods, Mercantile Agent CH II Chapter II — Formation (S.4-17) Sale vs Agreement to Sell (S.4) Conditions & Warranties (S.12-17) | Price (S.9-10) Quality/Fitness (S.16) | Sale by Sample (S.17) CH III Chapter III — Effects (S.18-30) Transfer of Property (S.18-25) — When ownership passes Risk passes with Property (S.26) Transfer of Title — Nemo Dat & 6 Exceptions (S.27-30) CH IV Chapter IV — Performance (S.31-44) Duties: Deliver (Seller) | Accept & Pay (Buyer) Delivery Rules: Place, Time, Quantity, Instalment Buyer's Right to Examine (S.41) | Acceptance (S.42) CH V Chapter V — Unpaid Seller (S.45-54) Unpaid Seller Defined (S.45) LIEN (S.47) | STOPPAGE IN TRANSIT (S.50-52) RIGHT OF RE-SALE (S.54) CH VI Chapter VI — Suits for Breach (S.55-61) SELLER: Suit for Price (S.55) | Non-Acceptance (S.56) BUYER: Non-Delivery (S.57) | Specific Performance (S.58) BOTH: Anticipatory Breach (S.60) | Interest (S.61) CH VII Chapter VII — Miscellaneous (S.62-66) Exclusion of Implied Terms (S.62) Auction Sales (S.64) | Tax Adjustments (S.64A) Savings (S.66) | Reasonable Time = Fact (S.63) GOAL COMPLETE ✅ MASTER THE SALE OF GOODS ACT, 1930 ⚠️ For Educational Purposes Only | Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, WB

📋 Key Comparison Tables — Quick Revision

All important comparisons at a glance for ICAI Members & Law Students

Table 1 — Sale vs. Agreement to Sell

#BasisSale (Executed)Agreement to Sell (Executory)
1Property TransferImmediateFuture/Conditional
2RiskPasses to Buyer immediatelyRemains with Seller
3TypeExecuted ContractExecutory Contract
4If goods perishBuyer's lossSeller's loss
5Right in remYes — against whole worldNo — only against Seller
6Buyer's insolvencySeller delivers; gets dividendSeller can retain goods
7Seller's insolvencyBuyer claims goodsBuyer gets dividend only

Table 2 — Condition vs. Warranty

BasisCondition (S.12(2))Warranty (S.12(3))
ImportanceESSENTIAL to main purposeCOLLATERAL to main purpose
Breach remedyRepudiate contract + DamagesDamages only
Can be downgraded?YES — S.13 (Condition → Warranty)NO — cannot be upgraded
ExampleGoods must be of specific qualityGoods to be delivered on time

Table 3 — Unpaid Seller's Three Rights

RightSectionConditionEffectLost When?
LienS.47-49Seller has possessionCan RETAIN goodsDelivers to carrier without reservation; Buyer gets possession; Waiver
Stoppage in TransitS.50-52Buyer INSOLVENT; goods in transitCan STOP goods during transitTransit ends; Carrier acknowledges for buyer
Right of Re-SaleS.54Perishable goods OR notice givenCan RESELL goods

Table 4 — Remedies for Breach

SectionRemedyAvailable ToCondition
S.55Suit for PriceSellerProperty passed AND buyer refuses to pay
S.56Damages for Non-AcceptanceSellerBuyer refuses to accept and pay
S.57Damages for Non-DeliveryBuyerSeller refuses/neglects to deliver
S.58Specific PerformanceBuyerSpecific/ascertained goods; Court's discretion
S.59Breach of Warranty RemedyBuyerDeduct from price OR sue for damages
S.60Anticipatory BreachEitherRepudiation before due date
S.61Interest & Special DamagesEitherWhere law allows — Court awards interest

Table 5 — Transfer of Property (When Ownership Passes)

SectionType of Goods/SituationWhen Property Passes
S.18Unascertained goodsNEVER until goods are ascertained
S.19Specific/ascertained goodsWhen parties INTEND
S.20Specific + deliverable + unconditionalWhen CONTRACT MADE
S.21Specific + seller must do somethingWhen thing DONE + buyer NOTIFIED
S.22Specific + weigh/measure for priceWhen act DONE + buyer NOTIFIED
S.23Unascertained/future + appropriationWhen UNCONDITIONALLY APPROPRIATED
S.24On approval / "sale or return"When APPROVAL SIGNIFIED or time lapses
S.25Seller reserves right of disposalWhen CONDITIONS FULFILLED
⚠️

📚 EDUCATIONAL DISCLAIMER: This resource is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal matters, consult a qualified legal practitioner. Content prepared by Digital E-Filing Coach | Amanuddin Education, Haldia, West Bengal. Intended for CA Members, Law Students & Financial Professionals.

Scroll to Top